Skip to content
This puzzle was bought as a gift. I was informed that it was pretty good quality, but can not give a first hand review of it.
Toronto Blue Jays™ Baseball Wooden Puzzle
Regular price
$44.90
Regular price
$59.90
Sale price
$44.90
Unit price
per
Couldn't load pickup availability
BUY MORE, SAVE MORE
Valid on all wooden puzzles · No code needed
BUY 2
15% OFF
BUY 3
20% OFF
BUY 4+
BEST SAVINGS
25% OFF
FREE SHIPPING
No minimum order
A Must-Have for Every Toronto Blue Jays Fan
✓ More than just a puzzle. Piece together your passion for the Toronto Blue Jays and create something you’ll be proud to complete, display, and keep.
✓ Made for fans and collectors. A unique piece of Toronto Blue Jays memorabilia that combines fandom, creativity, and the thrill of collecting.
✓ A gift they’ll actually remember. Beautifully presented in a premium wooden box, it’s a gift that feels different from the usual baseball merchandise.
Why You'll Love It
✓ Crafted from premium sustainable wood.
✓ Extra-thick 1/8 in (0.3 cm) pieces for a satisfying, premium feel.
✓ Unique baseball-inspired shapes hidden throughout the puzzle.
✓ Vibrant, detailed artwork designed to look amazing when completed.
✓ Made to be built, enjoyed, collected, and displayed.
Choose Your Challenge
S Small: 150 pieces · Approx. 2–3 hours
M Medium: 270 pieces · Approx. 4–6 hours
L Large: 500 pieces · Approx. 7–10 hours
From a fun afternoon challenge to hours of immersive puzzling, choose the experience that’s right for you.
Perfect For
• Adding something unique to your collection of Toronto Blue Jays memorabilia.
• Surprising a Toronto Blue Jays fan with a gift they won’t expect.
• Sharing the challenge with family, friends, or fellow Blue Jays fans.
• Displaying your passion once the final piece clicks into place.
Inside the Box
✓ 1x Toronto Blue Jays Wooden Puzzle
✓ 1x Premium Wooden Box with Puzzle Guide
Keep Shopping For Bundles!
View all-
New York Yankees™ Logo Wooden Puzzle
Regular price $44.90Regular priceUnit price per$59.90Sale price $44.90 -
New York Yankees™ Yankee Stadium Wooden Puzzle
Regular price $49.90Regular priceUnit price per$69.90Sale price $49.90 -
New York Yankees™ Baseball Wooden Puzzle
Regular price $44.90Regular priceUnit price per$59.90Sale price $44.90 -
New York Yankees™ Jersey Wooden Puzzle
Regular price $44.90Regular priceUnit price per$59.90Sale price $44.90 -
Los Angeles Dodgers™ Logo Wooden Puzzle
Regular price $44.90Regular priceUnit price per$59.90Sale price $44.90 -
Los Angeles Dodgers™ Dodger Stadium Wooden Puzzle
Regular price $49.90Regular priceUnit price per$69.90Sale price $49.90 -
Los Angeles Dodgers™ Baseball Wooden Puzzle
Regular price $44.90Regular priceUnit price per$59.90Sale price $44.90 -
Los Angeles Dodgers™ 2025 World Series Wooden Puzzle
Regular price $44.90Regular priceUnit price per$59.90Sale price $44.90 -
Los Angeles Dodgers™ Jersey Wooden Puzzle
Regular price $44.90Regular priceUnit price per$59.90Sale price $44.90 -
Los Angeles Dodgers™ 2024 World Series Wooden Puzzle
Regular price $44.90Regular priceUnit price per$59.90Sale price $44.90
Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 4.8 / 5 from 149 reviews.
A challenging puzzle, for sure. But feels like a great accomplishment when finished! Great quality, great service. Thank you to everyone at Iconic Puzzles. This will stay on our wall for many years to come!
Really challenging puzzle, but a great feeling when done! Stellar product, great company to deal with! Thank you, Iconic Puzzles!
A great puzzle.
We bought this for my mom who is having mobility issues and can’t get out much. She loves the Toronto Blue Jays and this gave her a really nice challenge!
It’s very unique and looks amazing when put together!
Lots of fun. A little hard to connect since it's very delicate but overall a great puzzle experience
Great service, great puzzle, pieces are amazing, structure is perfect.
Great challenge. Lots of fun. Great shapes of ball players
Loved putting it together. Can’t wait to get it up on the wall!
Very Interesting
Wow .. that was a lot harder then I first thought it would be ... But very Kool keep sake at the end.
Loved it!
The puzzle is Great!!! The color and cut of each piece is perfect!!!!
He loved the gift and thought it was so fun to put together. Top quality and so unique!
It's a amazing puzzle to do very fun and challenging I love how u players as peices awesome
Got this puzzle for my partner over Christmas and he is not normally the puzzle type. I couldn’t get him away from this one! He sat down to do it every evening until it was complete and he thought the different shaped pieces were so fun. The puzzle is very high quality. We now have 2 of these puzzles and will definitely be purchasing more for ourselves and as gifts for people. Definitely recommend!
Great puzzle.
That was the X-mas '22 to myself. I'ma fan for de J's since xxxx years. Started just this September putting it together. Once started, could hardly stop. Had a hard time to extend the finishing to 3 days! It was so much fun holding unic piece in hand and seeing the acurate details.
This is a great gift for a sports fan who has just about everything. The unique pieces make it fun and the finished puzzle will make a great display.
I bought this a gift for my baseball loving husband. He loved it! It was fun to put together, a little challenging at times though. Shipping was fast and the package arrived with no issues. Look forward to exploring other puzzles from Iconic.
It was so fun to make this puzzle with the players, bats, Blue Jays name as puzzle pieces. Would definitely recommend this to anyone who loves puzzles!!
We started this but I don’t have a recent picture. It is a very hard puzzle! It’s going to take us awhile haha! It’s well made though! Great quality. I do however wish the outline on the frame of the box for the puzzle was black instead of very light brown so you could cheat a little to connect the pieces together when you get stuck. So far we have spent about 20mins on it for a week and a bit and we have the blue Jay symbol done. It’s going to be beautiful once completed for sure :) while you’re putting it together you have to be very careful touching the pieces as it separated because the players don’t actually click into place (obviously ) but it’s been fun and a challenge for sure! Very happy! Worth the price!
This was an awesome puzzle! I would work on it while watching a game on tv. It was definitely challenging and I loved the fact that the pieces were different. I would recommend these puzzles to anyone who loves baseball! ⚾️⚾️⚾️
Thought it be be easy not! Lot's of of fun really enjoyed it. Good quality finished. took apart so I can do it again thank you
Loved our Blue Jays puzzle! It's a unique puzzle with all sorts of baseball themed jigsaw pieces! Much harder than it looks too.
I had so much fun doing it, I recommend it to all baseball fans
A beautifully made puzzle.
Many broken peices in the box.
One of the hardest puzzles I’ve ever done but it was worth it ! The 250 pieces is a great size, you can see all the intricate detail when it’s done !
It was a Christmas gift for my son and he loved it. Even had someone ask where he got it
This is my son’s second wall puzzle of his favorite team. It’s hours of fun and opportunities to chat with him about life! A win for all!
The puzzles that I bought are for 2026 birthday gifts. However, I love the one I received for Christmas. I expect my gifts will be well received.
It’s great, love it
Would not buy again. I was told the product was in Canada, only to learn it was shipped from China. It took longer to ship and so I could not give the gift at the event I was going to. False advertising
Gifted to my in-laws who are BJ superfans Loved it
IT I a nice Looking puzzle, just doesn’t click tightly together!
Very challenging puzzle but looks great!
Took a long time for delivery but it’s a great puzzle
I gave it to my daughter and her baseball mad family for Christmas. They loved it and spent Christmas evening and Boxing Day putting it together. They were trying to decide whether to redo it before mounting it.